Later, when her husband comes home, he tells her he doesn’t understand how she could have hit a car six times by accident. She even makes use of Igdie’s war cry of “Towanda! We will not remove any content for bad language alone, or being critical of a particular book. Sep 27, Ninny and Idgie were not the same person. They are good for each other! Again though, if the thought of those two women being together in a relationship and sharing physical and emotional intimacy intimidates readers that badly they can go on lying to themselves about it.

I think that Idgie loved Ruth from the time when Buddy loved Ruth. It serves therapists, teachers, and parents. Jul 01, Secondary to Idgie Threadgoode is her alter-ego, Ninny Threadgoode. The facts are narrow to it being true. In the book it is clear that they are not. I think Ruth and Idgie were lovers.

He informed me that I loved it because it was the gayest film of all time. But I think she really was Idgie. As for the relationship between Idgy and Ruth, I always wondered in the movie if they were lesbians or at least Idgy wanted Ruth, but feel it was definitely implied in the book. Fannie Flagg, Carol Sobieski Cast: Ruth gave birth to a son named Buddy Jr.

This is only a hazy memory, I haven’t seen the movie in years. Again, the film implies Ninny and Idgie are one and the same. Besides, there is way too much honey in the jar that can’t have come from the small piece of honeycomb she had collected. The only thing she doesn’t do is go into great sexual detail, but that is the same for all the characters in the novel. Later she married Cleo Threadgoode and had a mentally challenged son with him named Albert. In that news letter she clearly refers to Ninny and Idgie as separate people and also refers to Cleo as Ninny’s wife, Albert as her son and Idgie and Ruth as a couple.


There was a scene where Idgie spends the night elsewhere and Ruth is mad. Perhaps she changed her name because Patricia Neal, the actress might have been confused with the writer.

It is hinted at in the book a million times. This is the part that makes me feel like Ninny and Idgie are the same person.

Is Ninny Threadgoode really Idgie Threadgoode in fried green tomatoes?

Also the bee charmer was still alive, because Evelyn noticed the jar of honey and a note on Ruth’s headstone. It’s funny even the critics are confused and disagree about the relationship.

Were Ninny and Idgie the same person? Find showtimes, watch trailers, browse photos, track your Watchlist and rate your favorite movies and TV shows on your phone or tablet! Otis would notice if Idgie suddenly started calling herself Ninny Ruth talked about why she had to leave and marry Frank Bennett because their relationship Idgy and hers would never be accepted and Idgy was just a kid and had no idea what she was getting herself into. The neat thing is, as someone else said, it doesn’t matter to the story.

I would compare our friendship in every way to theirs. I am old enough to recall a time–not as far back as this was set, mind you–when being gay was considered by mainstream US culture to be almost as unnatural as sex with farm animals.

Endgame trailer 7 mistakes in Beetlejuice you never spotted Great movie trivia Captain Marvel trailer finally arrives I don’t understand why one would feel that it was disrespectful to their relationship to believe it was sexual in nature. I think that Idgie loved Ruth from the time when Buddy loved Ruth. Sep 25, A second thing my mom and sister said was that the setup of most of the relationships is slightly different in the book, and I guess in the book maybe it is clearer that Ninny and Idgie are different people.


At the beginning of the movie Buddy is run over by a train.

The film that makes me cry: Fried Green Tomatoes | Film | The Guardian

This is an attribute of truly creative storytelling. There’s a brief episode in the book where Ruth walks out on Idgie.

She’s the woman I can’t live without.

Also, I do not believe that Idgie and Ninny were the same person at all, if you look closely at the book. As a child, he had novie quite courageous when he confronted his older sister after she had lied to him. It gave me a new insight. Using the points made above, the other interpretation of Idgie and Ninny being the same person is addressed below: In the scene where Evelyn and Ninny eat fried green tomatoes on Ninny’s bed Ninny says “the Lord takes us home when he wants us”.

Why do you igdie that Flagg wasn’t clear on the subject.